July 05, 2013

At Balkinization, Sandy Levinson has some strong words for Chief Justice Roberts' opinion in Shelby County v. Holder:  Tendentious, mendacious or audacious? John Roberts rewrites the 10th Amendment.  As Professor Levinson says,

One of the most astounding sentences in Roberts’s egregious Shelby County opinion gutting the Voting Rights Act is the following (slip op., p. 9): "Indeed, the Constitution provides that all powers not specifically granted to the Federal Government are reserved to the States or citizens. Amdt. 10." (emphasis definitely added) This is, of course, a highly tendentious paraphrase of the text …

Further:

[T]he Constitution expressly does grant Congress the power to engage in all appropriate legislation to enforce the 15th Amendment's guarantee that the right to vote will not be denied because of race.  So the 10th Amendment has nothing whatsoever to do with the case. 

I agree that the word "specifically" seems doubtful — for example, Congress' necessary-and-proper powers are not "specifically" granted.  I also agree (even more emphatically) that the Tenth Amendment doesn't add anything to the Shelby County analysis.  As I've argued a number of times, the Tenth Amendment is a core part of the constitutional structure, as it precludes Congress from asserting extratextual powers.  But when Congress asserts textual powers, the Tenth Amendment has nothing to say: the question is just whether Congress' textual assertion is correct.

Nonetheless, I think Shelby County is much more defensible on originalist grounds than a number of people on the political left have suggested.   As Levinson says, the case turns on the Fifteenth Amendment's grant to Congress of power to enforce the Amendment.  But that is not the end of the debate.  Congress does not have power to "enforce this article [the Fifteenth Amendment] by legislation"; it has the power to "enforce this article [the Fifteenth Amendment] by appropriate legislation" (emphasis definitely added).  Whatever "appropriate" means in this context, it indicates some limit on Congress.

Thus the Court's opinion in Shelby County is saying that the preclearance coverage provisions of the Voting Rights Act are not "appropriate."  Reasonable minds can surely disagree on this point, but the structure of the opinion is consistent with a finding of inappropriateness: (1) preclearance disrupts the constitutional order by treating states unequally and interfering with states' ability to regulate voting; and (2) its differential treatment of states does not seem justified in light of modern conditions.

Of course one can say in response that the Court should defer to Congress on the question of appropriateness.  But that is more a role-of-the-Court claim than an originalist claim.  Originalists who believe in active judicial review should not have any fundamental problem with Shelby County.  And I would not think that people on the political left would want to say too much about the need for the Court to defer to Congress, given the result in United States v. Windsor.

Further note:  Related thoughts on Shelby County from Will Baude here.

Posted at 6:17 AM