March 25, 2012

Randy Barnett has this post in response to various commentators' defenses of the health care law, which among other things makes this important point:

… Justice Scalia’s concurring opinion in Raich in no way [binds] him to uphold the mandate.… Justice Scalia’s argument concerned only the meaning of the word “necessary” in the Necessary and Proper Clause, whereas our arguments [in the brief challenging the health care law] accept this analysis while stressing the meaning of “to carry into execution” and “proper.”  As his opinion in Raich says absolutely nothing about these portions of the Necessary and Proper Clause, Justice Scalia is neither committed to accepting or rejecting our arguments.  Perhaps most importantly, it is Justice Scalia who, above all Justices, has most greatly stressed (in Printz) that the issue of “proper” is distinct from that of “necessary.”

I think this goes to the heart of the debate, at least from a textualist/originalist perspective, in a way few commentators appreciate.  As I argued  earlier, I think one can show (especially in light of Scalia's Raich opinion) that the mandate is "necessary … for carrying into Execution" Congress' power to regulate interstate commerce.   As Professor Barnett indicates, the key is:  what is "proper"?

RELATED:  Damon W. Root: The 4 Best Legal Arguments Against ObamaCare (#1 is "The Individual Mandate Violates the Original Meaning of the Constitution").

Posted at 11:00 PM

January 03, 2012

History News Network has lesson plan for teachers, part of which focuses on comparing the concepts of “originalism” and “living document.”

Posted at 7:12 PM

December 18, 2011

Andrew Rosenthal: When in Doubt, Blame the Founders.

Posted at 7:45 AM

August 01, 2011

Daniel Levin: Does the Tea Party Love the Constitution?

Posted at 7:09 AM

June 01, 2011

Daniel Fisher on Progressives Wrestle With A Tough Sales Pitch.

Posted at 9:45 PM