June 17, 2012

In the July issue of Reason Magazine, Damon W. Root has a long article on the background of the health care litigation: ObamaCare on Trial: The Libertarian Legal Movement Threatens Barack Obama's Signature Law.

The New York Times has this account: How Broccoli Landed on Supreme Court Menu.  At Volokh Conspiracy, Ilya Somin comments:

The article includes some interesting facts, but it ultimately misses the point. The mandate’s legal problems are not the result of some clever rhetorical gambit about broccoli. In fact, the broccoli analogy is not a significant point in itself, but merely a useful shorthand for the key flaw in the federal government’s defense of the mandate: the fact that all the arguments in its favor would also justify pretty much any other mandate Congress might care to impose, and would therefore lead to structurally unlimited federal power. If the government’s reasoning would make a broccoli mandate constitutional, it can be used to justify virtually anything.

Posted at 6:00 PM