October 19, 2013

At NRO, Ed Whelan has a two-part review of Originalism and the Good Constitution by John McGinnis and Michael Rappaport (Harvard Univ. Press 2013): part 1 here and part 2 here.  From the introduction:

Originalism and the Good Constitution is an impressive work, rich with interesting and intelligent arguments. In developing their normative argument for originalism, McGinnis and Rappaport stake out and defend various positions on contested points of originalist methodology. Their book will surely play a prominent role in the ongoing debate over originalism.

The review goes on to offer two criticisms: in part 1, that McGinnis & Rappaport's justification for originalism is not the most persuasive one, and in part 2, that they do not have a satisfactory account of precedent.

Posted at 6:27 AM