Rosalind Dixon (University of Chicago- Law School) and Richard Holden (University of Chicago) have posted Constitutional Amendment Rules: The Denominator Problem (Comparative Constitutional Design, Tom Ginsburg ed., 2011; U of Chicago, Public Law Working Paper No. 346) on SSRN. Here is the abstract:
The difficulty of constitutional amendment, in most contexts, clearly depends on both the formal rules governing amendment and a variety of other factors. This chapter explores the significance one such non-textual factor: the size, or scale, of a polity. It, first, identifies a number of theoretical reasons to think that the “denominator” for constitutional amendment purposes may affect the difficulty of amendment in a jurisdiction; and second, uses an original dataset on constitutional amendments at a state-level in the US, and the size of state legislatures, to show a clear negative relationship between actual amendment denominators and the rate of constitutional amendment, in various US states.
Posted at 7:00 AM