People interested in the Privileges or Immunities Clause may like to read a new Note from the Harvard Law Review, suggesting a role for Congress in determining what is included in the phrase “privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States.” The HLR Note is titled Congress’s Power to Define the Privileges and Immunities of Citizenship, 128 Harv. L. Rev. 1206 (Feb 10, 2015). In my view, this Note in the HLR is missing some important ingredients.
It is amazing how many journal articles that focus exclusively upon this Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment somehow overlook the origin of the key quoted phrase. Less than a month before the phrase first appeared in a draft of the Fourteenth Amendment, President Andrew Johnson doubted, in the official message accompanying his veto of the Civil Rights Act, whether newly-freed slaves possessed the “requisite qualifications to entitle them to all the privileges and immunities of citizens of the United States.” You can search through Hein Online, and find only seven scholarly articles quoting that statement by President Johnson — the HLR Note not among them.
The veto message stated that the question would not arise (about requisite qualifications) if one assumes that the Constitution always deemed native-born persons to be citizens of the United States; Johnson thus took the position that the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States exist automatically as a result of U.S. citizenship, not as a result of statutory selection. That is a big deal, and goes to the core of what the new Note in the HLR is about. Yet Johnson was not done explaining his terminology. He added that a foreigner, upon completing the naturalization process, receives a “coveted prize” by attaining “the rights of citizens as contemplated by the Constitution of the United States,” as distinguished from the rights listed in the Civil Rights Act which the foreigner may be given even before citizenship is granted. This confirms that Johnson, in a formal and widely-reported way, defined the “privileges and immunities of citizens of the United States” as the rights that attach to U.S. citizenship under the Constitution. It therefore seems clear that Congress generally has no substantive role by virtue of the Privileges or Immunities Clause; as far as I am aware, no supporter of the Fourteenth Amendment during that era disagreed with or contradicted Johnson's understanding of the term "privileges and immunities of citizens of the United States."
The HLR Note does refer to a Congressman Charles Phelps (who was an opponent of the Fourteenth Amendment); Phelps argued that Congress would have power to define the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States "in like manner" as it has power to define who are citizens. However, the HLR Note neglects to mention that Phelps' statement (on May 5, 1866) was followed by the addition of the Citizenship Clause to the Fourteenth Amendment (on May 30, 1866), thus removing power from Congress. The HLR Note also mentions a speech by Congressman Andrew Rogers (another opponent of the Fourteenth Amendment), but Rogers did not specify which branch of the federal government would determine what the privileges and immunities of U.S. citizens are, though it is true that Rogers took a very different position than Johnson did. Anyway, the HLR Note is interesting, allbeit incomplete and mistaken, in my opinion.
Posted at 9:33 AM