Thomas H. Lee (Fordham University School of Law) has posted The Citizenship Clause’s Residence Requirement (82 pages) on SSRN. Here is the abstract:
The debate about President Trump’s January 20, 2025 Executive Order denying automatic American citizenship to children born in the United States to unlawfully or temporarily present foreign parents is divided into two polar-opposite camps asserting that it’s wholly constitutional or wholly unconstitutional. In a new academic paper, I make the case that the 1868 original meaning of the Fourteenth Amendment’s Citizenship Clause supports a middle position: a child born in the United States to alien parents is automatically a citizen if the parents reside in the United States even if they entered unlawfully, but the child is not a citizen if the alien parents are in the United States as temporary sojourners, like tourists. This original, revisionist interpretation of the Citizenship Clause is faithful to the Clause’s text and original meaning and also consistent with the Constitution’s other citizenship-related provisions, relevant Supreme Court decisions, and the larger, evolving context of domestic and international citizenship controversies the Clause was ratified to address, while recovering an original meaning that sensibly speaks to modern realities.
AND ON THE SAME SUBJECT:
Kurt Lash (University of Richmond School of Law) has posted The Allegiance Reading of the Citizenship Clause and Its Critics: A Response (102 Notre Dame L. Rev. (forthcoming 2026) (27 pages) on SSRN (further defending a narrow originalist view of birthright citizenship that is the inverse of Professor Lee’s — that is, it would exclude children of unlawful entrants but include children of temporary visitors, while Professor Lee would do the opposite). Here is the abstract:
The Fourteenth Amendment establishes two requirements for natural born citizenship: First, one must be born in the United States. Second, one also must be born “subject to the jurisdiction” of the United States. In a prior article, I explained how the framers and ratifiers understood the latter text as requiring that one be born subject to the sovereign people of the United States in the sense of owing a primary allegiance to the United States. In a recent essay, Professor Michael Ramsey [ed.: in this article] critiques the allegiance theory and argues that the text should be read to include any person born in the United States subject to its lawful or “sovereign authority.”
Professor Ramsey’s reading is thoughtful but cannot be correct. Ramsey substitutes the phrase “under sovereign authority” for the actual text “subject to the jurisdiction” of the United States, and he invests it with a meaning based on common law instead of the actual understanding of the framers and ratifiers. The result is an interpretation held by congressional Democrats but expressly rejected by the Republican framers. Nor can Ramsey’s “subject to sovereign authority” theory account for the exclusion of the one category everyone involved insisted be excluded: children born to Native American parents.
Most of all, Ramsey cannot explain away the abundant historical evidence supporting an 1866 allegiance-based understanding of natural born citizenship. In one of the most widely published speeches of the Thirty-Ninth Congress, and one that Ramsey does not mention, John Bingham explained that “every human being born within the jurisdiction of the United States of parents not owing allegiance to any foreign sovereignty is, in the language of your Constitution itself, a natural-born citizen.” Both the 1866 Civil Rights Act and the Fourteenth Amendment communicated this same Republican theory of natural born citizenship.
Briefly in response: (a) I don’t “substitute” “subject to sovereign authority” for “subject to the jurisdiction”; that is literally what “jurisdiction” meant, in dictionaries and common legal discourse of the time. (b) I’m not aware of anything in the “actual understanding of the framers and ratifiers” directly to the contrary. (c) My theory “accounts” for the exclusion of Native Americans in the same way the drafters did: Native tribes were not subject to U.S. jurisdiction as to most internal tribal matters, And (d), as I discuss in my article, I don’t see how the occasional references to “not owing allegiance to any foreign sovereignty” supports Professor Lash at all, and he doesn’t explain how they do. If that were the Fourteenth Amendment’s test, in the sense Professor Lash reads it, it would exclude all U.S.-born children of aliens, a result the drafters specifically rejected and which Professor Lash does not accept. There is no sense in which that phrase excludes only children of unlawful entrants. And in any event, that is simply not what “subject to the jurisdiction” meant. One can be “subject to the jurisdiction” of one sovereign while also “owing allegiance to” another sovereign — this is, for example, the situation of every U.S. citizen travelling abroad.
I think we will now need to have a moratorium on birthright citizenship on this blog. At least for a while.
Posted at 6:03 AM