Ken Kersch has this interesting post at Balkinization, which begins:
A huge amount of “popular” constitutional discourse these days – on the internet, on TV, etc. – is constituted by quotations from the Founders. Many of these, of course, are wrenched out of the context, not only of their times, but even of the broader framework of the thinking of the quoted Founder himself, who may actually hold positions directly opposite to those for which he is purported to stand. Most populist originalism takes place on the Right, so it’s not surprising that I’ve come across very little of it that speaks to the Founders concerns with economic inequality. Since, back around the time of Charles Beard, liberals/progressives lost the habit of basing their political arguments on appeals to the (eighteenth century) Founders, much of the originalist discourse of economic inequality is thus missing from contemporary constitutional debate. (To the extent they engage in originalist argument on the theme of equality, liberals – reflecting a preoccupation with race and (later) sex, and not economics — focus almost entirely on the Civil War Amendments.).
We know from other contexts, though, that there was lots of discussion of economic inequality at the time of the (eighteenth century) Founding. Much of this discussion was constitutional….
Posted at 7:00 AM