Brent J. Horton (Fordham University Schools of Business) has posted How Dodd-Frank's Orderly Liquidation Authority for Financial Companies Violates Article III of the United States Constitution (Journal of Corporation Law, Vol. 36, No. 4, p. 869, 2011) on SSRN. Here is the abstract:
Title II of Dodd-Frank empowers the Treasury to appoint a receiver to a state-chartered non-bank financial company — a power traditionally vested in the judiciary — with little or no judicial involvement. This Article argues that granting such power to the Treasury violates Article III of the United States Constitution, which explicitly vests the judicial power in Article III courts. It begins with a discussion of Supreme Court precedent, specifically cases challenging legislative enactments that arguably vest judicial power in an executive agency or non-article III court, including Crowell v. Benson, Northern Pipeline v. Marathon and CFTC v. Schor.
This Article then turns to Article II of Dodd-Frank, and whether its grant of power to the Treasury is improper? In so doing, it examines the origins of the power to appoint a receiver. Looking back 200 years, this Article argues that the power to appoint a receiver was traditionally vested in courts of equity. Powers traceable to the courts of equity are now vested in Article III courts.
Finally, this Article shifts gears and examines whether — if the Treasury did appoint a receiver to a non-bank financial company — there is adequate Article III judicial review of the appointment. The conclusion is that judicial review is wanting: the scope of review is limited to confirming that the company is in danger of defaulting, and that the company is indeed financial in nature; and the standard of review is limited to determining whether that finding was arbitrary and capricious. Finally, the judicial review must be complete its review within 24 hours, an impossible task.
Posted at 6:33 AM