At Volokh Conspiracy, David Bernstein: Consensus or diversity among originalists? (continuing the discussion with Will Baude — see prior posts here and here). From the beginning of the post:
In particular, I don’t think that … “interpreting the Constitution according to its original meaning” should be interpreted to require that the Constitution be interpreted clause-by-clause without regard to whether the broader scheme set up by the Framers is lost in the process (for example, when the prior misinterpretation of one clause disrupts the constitutional balance in ways that might affect how other clauses should be interpreted).
I do think, however, that normative originalism as practiced by its leading American academic advocates generally exclusively involves clause-by-clause interpretation. By contrast, scholars who try to engage in holistic analysis, perhaps like my colleague Michael Greve, are often deemed to be “not really originalists.”
Posted at 11:30 PM